Showing posts with label Albums of the Year. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Albums of the Year. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 19, 2018

Albums of the Year, 2018

I paid more attention this year, which is why I probably think it's been a 'good' year for new music, and why I'm bothering with a list for the first time since 2012. With the usual disclaimer that even if I'd listened to every record released in 2018 at least 15 times over, this list of favourites (as opposed to 'the best') would still be random and entirely subjective, and would read differently tomorrow compared with how I've aligned the albums today. Did I really like Halo Maud's record marginally less than Marisa Anderson's? Should you rank Oneohtrix Point Never's music side by side with Fatoumata Diawara's? Probably not. But here we go anyway: 

40. Vera Sola- Shades (Spectraphonic)
39. Rosanne Cash- She Remembers Everything (Blue Note)
38. Karine Polwart- Laws of Motion (Hudson)
37. Selling, Gold Panda & jas Shaw- On Reflection (City Slang)
36. Bombino- Deran (Partisan)
35. Liela Moss- My Name Is Safe In Your Mouth (Bella Union)
34. The Field- Infinite Moment (Kompakt)
33. Robyn- Honey (Embassy One)
32. Mark Lanegan & Duke Garwood- With Animals (Heavenly)
31. Lubomyr Melnyk- Fallen Trees (Erased Tapes)
30. Natalie Prass- The Future and the Past (ATO)
29. Aidan Moffat & RM Hubbert- Here Lies the Body (Rock Action Records)
28. Vanessa Peters- Foxhole Prayers (Idol Records)
27. Halo Maud- Je suis une île (Heavenly)

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Top 30 Albums, 2012


At last, it's the end-of-year musical list that all stay-at-home dads long for and live for. I won't bore you with too much prose this time, having long since run out of new adjectives to describe sounds that deserve more than mere phrases. As always, this is in no way a professionally assessed list, it's a rundown of the recordings I enjoyed listening to most, in approximate order. My apologies to the thousands of artistes I never heard, or have never heard of. It was already a good enough year without me needing to hear any more.

30. Tift Merritt - Traveling Alone (Yep Roc)
Track: Traveling Alone
Listen to: ooh, I don't know. When traveling alone?


29. Cat Power - Sun (Matador Records)
TrackCherokee
Listen to: still traveling alone, dreamily driving across vast, unpopulated midwest landscapes (never done this, but it's a plan).

28. Air - Le Voyage dans la Lune (EMI)
TrackSonic Armada
Listen to: while watching the disconcerting 1902 sci-fi film of the same name that Air belatedly put a soundtrack to.

27. Mark Lanegan Band - Blues Funeral (4AD)
Listen to: while celebrating decay.

26. Amadou and Mariam - Folilo (Nonesuch)
TrackOh Amadou
Listen to: when reading reports from northern Mali about how brutal Islamic fundamentalists are suppressing all forms of music beside religious incantations.

25. Alabama Shakes - Boys and Girls (Ato Records)
TrackHold On
Listen to: for old-fashioned musical virtues - raw, head-ripping, down-to-the-bone brilliance.

24. Cate le Bon - Cyrk (TCG)
Listen to: when you're wishing the Velvet Underground and Nico had made a few more albums.

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

2011 Albums of the Year

This year I return to the tried and trusted formula of the meaninglessly numbered list. The reason? I looked at last year’s entry to see which album I’d chosen as my number one, and was disappointed to find I hadn’t bothered. Too lazy, I reckon, and it wasn’t a particularly good year. This year, though, I was spoilt for choice, and so (already thrilled readers, musicians and music biz executives), I gift you the shivering anticipation of the countdown. As ever, my criterion was simple: I chose albums I wanted to keep playing, again and again. It’s not really a list of records classified for technical or creative or cultural reasons, but a list of albums I most fell in love with (though from around number 30 downwards it’s less love, and more ‘fancied a lot/bit’).

20. Beirut – The Rip Tide (Pompeii Records)
With this band, you feel that anything’s possible, although more than likely it will involve brass bands and some kind of folk influence from an unlikely source. iTunes laughably classifies this as “indie-rock”. Think of any other combination of genres besides indie-rock, throw them into a catalytic converter and let Beirut toy with the result using seductive syncopation, blasted riffs, and a pale but fetching vocal. Track you’d want your town band to play at the annual parade: The Rip Tide

Classically Deathcabbish
19. Death Cab For Cutie – Coats and Keys (Atlantic)
I sometimes buy albums by bands like Death Cab For Cutie out of a sense of duty that they’re the kind of band I ought to be into, rather than actually being into. So it’s always a pleasant surprise when their records turn out to be far better than I’d expected. This is a solid, archetypally articulate DeathCabbish collection, though it sometimes takes years for their best songs to sink in – I only realized when I saw them live how much I love their earlier work. Indie-pop track to the core: Doors Unlocked And Open. Advice I won’t take track: Stay Young, Go Dancing.

18. The Feelies – Here Before (Bar/None)
Seeing as no one makes blissfully good old-style indie-pop any more, call back the old hands that did it right the first time around, as the album title hints. Okay, second time around, given that so many 1980s bands like The Feelies and Galaxie 500/Luna unblushingly but very successfully rode on the riffs of the Velvet Underground. They’ve still got what they always had – cheerfully shambolic but somehow addictive scratchy guitars on top of understated vocals in a world beyond Autotune. Track to dance badly to while wearing your retired leather jacket, smoking a cigarette and drinking get-pissed-quick, extra-strength lager: the whole album

Monday, December 20, 2010

Albums of the Year, 2010

Bonnie Prince B and his funny folk.
The following are in no particular order, a glance at previous years’ lists having confirmed that allocating a number next to any one album results in an arbitrary ranking of no long term significance. Fewer ‘reviews’ this year too, as finding fresh rhetorical ways to convey a pleasure in what are often the same bands (reflecting an increasingly static taste) becomes an annual challenge I’m losing the will to confront. Also, when I read a year-end list at a worthy, knowledgeable website like The Quietus, I get the feeling that, in any case, I’ve probably been listening in all the wrong places. Or maybe there really is nothing much of note released nowadays that can impress a mid-life indie-pop. After all, my favourite release of the year isn’t on this list because it was the boxed set re-issue of the entire Orange Juice back catalogue from the early 1980s, Coals To Newcastle. So it’s a rough Top 11, followed by a list of secondary choices.

Bonnie “Prince” Billy & The Cairo Gang - The Wonder Show Of The World (Drag City)
Another year, and another wonderfully realised record of melodic narratives cloaked in raw, emotive beauty. Track to try: Troublesome Houses.

Sun Kil Moon - Admiral Fell Promises (Caldo Verde)
Shhhhhh... Soothing gorgeousness now comes with sporadic flamenco guitar riffs. But they work wondrously, as do most things created by a man in a perennial audition to play the soundtrack to Eternity. Track to try: Third and Seneca

Gayngs – Related (Jagjaguwar)
A gift box of styles and surprises built on a glowing fire-bed of compelling hooks. Track to try: The Gaudy Side of Town

Phosphorescent - Here’s To Taking It Easy (Dead Oceans)
Wins the award for least agit-prop album title since Black Lace’s last party LP. This record also more than makes up for the absence of any Jason Molina/Magnolia Electric Co. output this year, though it’s inspired enough by the latter to stand alone as an Americana landmark. Track to try: Los Angeles

Laura Veirs - July Flame (Bella Union)
Seventh album of fluttering, quirky brilliance could even be her best yet. Track to try: Life Is Good Blues

Tuesday, December 08, 2009

Top 30 Albums, 2009

It’s already that time of year when music executives gather restlessly around a wireless, clutching semi-unplugged bottles of chilled Bollinger and waiting for the BBC World Service to announce this blog’s top 30 albums of the year. Setting the benchmark for middle-ageing indie-farts since 2004, my carefully researched list - a more or less arbitrary ranking of most of the albums that one individual just happens to have bought this year - is seen by music lovers across the globe as the industry standard pointer towards buying seasonal gifts for people they intensely dislike, usually the family’s aloof musical snob with an inflated sense of his own importance, especially where it concerns musical taste. You’re welcome.

30. The Avett Brothers – I And Love And You
There seem to be less albums like this around these days, filled with muscular, emotional, country-influenced music. As serious and as musically deep as you’d expect with Rick Rubin producing, the fundamentals here are fiddles, philosophy and a vocal finesse that underpin a solid, if sometimes overly safe set.
29. Monsters Of Folk – Monsters of Folk
Indie super group featuring M Ward, Conor Oberst, Mike Mogis and Jim James, with each contributing a handful of songs, all too easily recognisable in Oberst’s case. It’s a broadly successful collaboration, though, which thankfully has as much relation to R&B (on the superb opener ‘Dear God’), rock, pop and country as it does to folk.
28. Dead Man’s Bones – Dead Man’s Bones
Why didn’t I think of this? Indie-mood, electro sounds composed by a pair of actors backed sparingly by a children’s choir. Could be a disaster, but it’s quite the opposite, despite the juvenile band name.
27. Bonnie “Prince” Billy – Beware
Another year, and another immaculate slow-burner of a record from one of America’s most prolific, consistent songwriters. As ever, it’s not exactly packed with laughs and party tunes, just the usual low key musical musing on love, loss and death. So, something for everyone.

26. The Pastels/Tenniscoats – Two Sunsets
Fancy a nice cup of twee? Check out this Scottish/Japanese indie-pop collaboration. Glasgow fey may have had its day (give Stuart Murdoch’s tame God Help the Girl project a miss), but the two groups here work off each other to produce a neat little box of spangly gems, if you’ve got a quiet half hour to spare.
25. Alela Diane – To Be Still
I’m still a sucker for a Joni-influenced girl with an acoustic guitar if the voice, the songs and the string-picking can endure over the course of a whole disc (although this voice may not to be to everyone’s taste). Catch a thousand copyists in a coffee house near you, but none as good as this.
24. Califone – All My Friends Are Funeral Singers
If you’ve ever wondered what an album recorded in an old barn by possibly drunk musicians messing around with dusty equipment would sound like, then welcome to Califone. From the lo-fi doodlings there eventually emerges some half-realised, rough-cut jewels. Perhaps there’s more scheme to this than seems apparent from the end result, but I prefer to believe they just put it out the way they recorded it. Categorise under ‘experimental country/broken folk.’
23. Manchester Orchestra – Mean Everything To Nothing
I think it was on the letters page of Paste magazine that someone described Manchester Orchestra as “ridiculously derivative”, but that’s probably just because they’re from the grunge states. True, they still channel that 90s sound through big guitars and interludes of introspection that sometimes verge on the timeworn, but they have the songs, as well as an overt flair and bite to their delivery, that allows them to carry it off.
22. Eels – Hombre Lobo
Nothing much unexpected here from Mr E, but he’s one of the elite who can pull off delivering stylistically similar sets, thanks to the inherent strength of his compositions, fuelled by the throaty, soulful suffering of a lead voice that mixes the sour with the sardonic, while never forgetting the importance of delivering a tune.
21. Jah Wobble – Chinese Dub
Best Chinese folk-influenced dub album of the year. Oh heck, ever.
20. Royksopp – Junior
I love the simple things in life, like thoughtfully manufactured electronic pop. It’s easy to digest, and if taken in limited doses you never lose your taste for it, even if you would never throw yourself upon its practitioners and passionately proclaim them harbingers of the world’s most indispensable art. More likely you’d say, “Nice work, keep pressing those buttons.”
19. Maria Taylor – Lady Luck
We all love Maria in the Indie-Pop household, reliably recording a fine album every couple of years, and half-packing them in at the Rock and Roll Hotel, where we all get lost to ‘Song Beneath The Song’ at the end of a beer-travelled night.Lady Luck is another very decent collection, although slightly patchier than her first two superb efforts. 11:11 and Lynn Teeter Flower.
18. Metric – Fantasies
This band remind me of Blondie, in that they write nakedly commercial pop songs boasting enough punch and power to keep them bouncing around your sub-conscience, but in a rewarding rather than an irritating way. And yes, I still love Parallel Lines.
17. Sufjan Stevens – The BQE
Stevens recently told Paste that since this classically-oriented project, presented here with a mesmerising film fixed on and around the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, he’s lost the ability to write ‘normal’ songs. So the 50-album project, with each record focused on an individual US state, is on hold for now, 48 states short of its target. In the meantime, lose yourself in this astonishing journey, where he uses alternately manic and reflective composition to transform an unwieldy, traffic-clogged concrete artery through New York into an absorbing mirror of the urban human condition. Brave, fascinating, disconcerting and musically moving, all in one culturally packed package.
16. Magnolia Electric Company – Josephine
MEC’s mournful latest is a stripped down song cycle that apparently laments the titular subject, but on the band’s admittance is more of a loose tribute to its late bassist, Evan Farrell. It avoids the descent into dirge that has occasionally blighted Jason Molina’s voluminous and mostly magnificent past register of grey cloud, country-blues. It’s hard to imagine Molina as a London resident now - every note of this record is steeped in the feel of a vast and lonely America.
15. Modest Mouse – No One’s First, And You’re Next
There’s no group in the world that sounds remotely like Modest Mouse. Their nonsensical name underlies a twisted creativity that can be initially off-putting, but which ultimately draws you into a musical universe where so much is going on that there’s barely enough space in every song for all the weird ideas and tortured riffs that are kicking around. Persevere, and the rewards are durable.
14. Andrew Bird – Noble Beast
It takes some kind of peculiar genius to finger-pluck a violin, whistle, and not just desist from spoiling but actually improve already excellent songs. Even though this is not Bird’s best album, that only speaks for the extraordinary quality of his back catalogue. Added award: best live act of 2009, on a dream ticket with Loney, Dear at the 9:30 Club.
13. Neko Case – Middle Cyclone
Stunning, smart, shockingly gifted, Neko Case gets better with every album. Bold as a banker grasping for a bonus, every song demands your attention and, in the end, your appreciation. Case’s New Pornographers band mate AC Newman put out a good enough album with Guilty, but he must have listened to this with some measure of envy and conceded, “She’s the best.”
12. Vieux Farka Toure – Fondo
Imagine a record by Vieux’s father, the late Ali Farka Toure, played on electric guitar, and you have an idea of the extra sonic dimension added to what Vieux has happily inherited – a gift for vocal palliatives, understated rhythm, controlled improvisation (if that’s not an oxymoron), and overwhelming beauty.
11. Brandi Carlile – Give Up The Ghost
Anthemic, brash, cool… the abc of Brandi, and I could go on to devilish, euphoric, fresh but fragile, and beyond (to gargantuan, hoarse-heavenly, incandescent), but all I want to really do is pathetically declare my love. Mindy Smith and Tift Merritt were just one-off flings, Brandi. This is your third album, and you’ve still got me.
10. Iron & Wine – Around The Well
It says something for the depth of Sam Beam’s exhaustive library that a double CD collection of b-sides, outtakes and cover versions can compete with the year’s best recordings. Maybe it’s because this mostly takes us back to the sparse format of his wonderful early records, with just a voice and an acoustic guitar. Two whole sides of bliss.
9. Jason Lytle – Yours Truly, The Commuter
No longer Grandaddy in name, but very much a continuation of the older generation’s genre. If that group’s thick, creamy pop sound was your favourite indulgence, then a dollop of this will sweeten your ears too.
8. Au Revoir Simone - Still Night, Still Light
Pop angels sent to soothe you with synthesisers and sisterly singing along the lines of, “I’m moving on/I hope you’re coming with me…” Definitely.
7. Kings of Convenience – Declaration of Dependence
Maestros of melody produce a third irresistible album of wistful, guitar-led singalongs. Impossible not to love.
6. Marc Almond – Orpheus In Exile: The Songs of Vadim Kozin
Almond’s albums veer between seductive twilight dance electronica and collections of atavistic, cabaret-style, Brecht-Weillian numbers, but either way he’s a genius who deserves a ton of recognition for his lifetime achievements. This album is in the latter camp, featuring the folk songs of a little-known Russian folk singer of the early 20th century, and perfectly suited to Almond’s strong but sensitive vocals on top of perfectly realised arrangements that speckle the songs’ traditional timbre with minimalist technological touches.
5. Wilco – Wilco (The Album)
A cogent piece on the excellent Quietus music site posited the theory that Wilco are, quite simply, boring. It was a well-constructed argument, and I could see where the writer was coming from, but unfortunately the theory is wrong. This album - Wilco’s seventh or eighth, probably - should by rights be boring. Just look at the disingenuously dull title. And most bands are churning it out long before this point. Except that it isn’t - it’s brief, and it’s brilliant, their most accessible, least indulgent ever slice of whatever we’re calling ‘Americana’ these days.
4. Loney, Dear – Dear John
The subtle crescendos of Loney, Dear take you on a most relaxing rollercoaster ride, with enough warmly crafted songs to make this one of the year’s most endlessly repeatable releases.
3. Baaba Maal – Television
“Africa is the future” declares a sleeve note slogan, and if it sounds this good, the future will be shaped by hope and harmony. The record stacks a fuller sound on top of Maal’s trademark intricate acoustic work, fusing traditional rhythms with plangent bass lines and vocals that straddle a range from didactic urgency to tender crooning.
2. Anna Ternheim – Leaving On A Mayday
The darkness and the rain drive this Swedish nightingale, whose Nordic litost is matched only by her peerless delivery and immaculate songwriting. An almost perfect record.
1. Malcolm Middleton – Waxing Gibbous
Melancholy, bitter and thoroughly Celtic may not seem a high enough recommendation until you throw in Middleton’s extreme gift of being able to shroud his misery - darkly awash with the smile-shy humour at which Scotland excels - in consistently addictive, even invigorating tunes. Life is grim, but you can turn it into something dark, funny and beautiful, even as the rain keeps coming down.
The next 20:
31. Aidan Moffat and the Best-Ofs – How To Get To Heaven From Scotland
32. Twinkle 3 – Let’s Make A Solar System
33. Wye Oak – The Knot
34. Elvis Costello – Secret, Profane and Sugarcane
35. The Handsome Family – Honey Moon
36. Heartless Bastards – The Mountain
37. Beirut – March of the Zapotec/Realpeople Holland
38. Dan Deacon – Bromst
39. Camera Obscura – My Maudlin Career
40. Mindy Smith – Stupid Love
41. M Ward – Hold Time
42. Hope Sandoval and the Warm Invention – Through The Devil Softly
43. AC Newman – Get Guilty
44. Osso & Sufjan Stevens – Run Rabbit Run
45. Lisa Hannigan – Sea Sew
46. The Nightingales – Insult To Injury
47. Steve Earle – Townes
48. Atlas Sound – Logos
49. Air – Love 2
50. Regina Spektor – Far
Previous years:

Monday, December 15, 2008

The Actual Top 30 Albums Of 2008

The music industry is, as ever, known to be in a state of tension and barely concealed panic in the run-up to the annual Stay At Home Indie-Pop nominations for the year's best music. This year, due to the linguistic recession that has resulted in the chronic global shortage of adjectives, and bearing in mind that there are now approximately 700 blogs to every internet reader, reviews have been curtailed to a succinct and time-saving single sentence.


30. Her Space Holiday - XOXO, Panda And The New Kid Revival
After several wonderful albums of bedroom electro-pop for depressives, HSH makes a quirky guitar album full of hooks and funny, strange lyrics.

29. Sonya Kitchell - This Storm
19, gifted and beautiful, still feeling her way down different avenues -- her record company probably wants her to be Alanis Morissette, while she'd rather be Sonny Girl Williamson.

28. Lucinda Williams - Little Honey
Rocking, growling Lucinda got lucky in love at last, but she hasn't let that tame her style.

27. Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Weird but brilliant modern medieval music.

26. Tift Merritt - Another Country
C&W prodigy moves to Paris with a piano and gets all grown up on us.

25. Dawn Landes - Fireproof
This year's statutory emerging, sensitive New York songbird.

24. Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
We all know - written in an isolated shed for instant indie cred, but while it has its moments, it's too ponderous and maudlin to be as good as the critics wanted it to be.

23. Robert Forster - The Evangelist
Back solo from the Go-Betweens after Grant McLennan's death, a sombre, poetic effort built on Forster's unmistakable melodies.

22. She & Him - Volume One
Paste magazine made this its album of the year, an overly high accolade for what is a middling-to-good 60s pop revival record.

21. Toumani Diabate - The Mande Variations
Classical African music for meditative moments.

20. Yoav - Charmed And Strange
Accessible and at times exceptional electronica.

19. Paul Weller - 22 Dreams
Like a style-by-style career retrospective, but with entirely new and mostly fresh-sounding songs.

18. Portishead - Third
Closely related to First and Second, mixing brash with mellow deep inside the musical twilight zone.

17. Spiritualized - Songs In A & E
A record that only occasionally suffers from the scope of its ambition, with surprise largely accompanied by scarred sonic delight.

16. Tindersticks - The Hungry Saw
Oblivious to musical fads, still crafting the same quivering compositions of fragile beauty.

15. Giant Sand - proVISIONS
Low key, bass-driven soundtrack to the imminent greater depression - same formula, possibly better than ever.

14. Horse Feathers - House With No Home
Folk music scratched from the cold, raw earth with love and a battered fiddle.

13. Lie Down In The Light - Bonnie 'Prince' Billy
Upbeat enough compared with previous works that it should be subtitled: Will Oldham Finally Got Laid

12. M83 - Saturdays = Youth
Brimming with warm, vibrant synths - a record you can dig into like a bag of colorful, comforting sweets.

11. Old 97's - Blame It On Gravity
Plenty old, borrowed and blue, but you can't help but love a record full of lively, extremely singable songs.

10. Musee Mecanique - Hold This Ghost
Occasionally cloying, but mostly like coming in from the cold to hot chocolate and cake, all fuzzy synths wrapped in a soothing voice that envelops you in a blissful zone you may not want to leave.

9. Buika - Nina Del Fuego
You can almost smell the smoking danger in Buika's passionate, irresistible delivery.

8. Orchestra Baobab - Made In Dakar
Phenomenal musicians of unrelenting tempo and talent revelling in the usual maelstrom of joyous, soul-shaking styles.

7. Basia Bulat - Oh, My Darling
Delicate but lovely vocals underpin an album that slowly grows into a work of variety and finesse.

6. Kathleen Edwards - Asking For Flowers
Strong songs, tough themes and impeccable delivery from hugely gifted Canadian.

5. TV On The Radio - Dear Science
Much easier to like and listen to than any previous releases, this is an impressive series of rhythmic rides into the realm of the unexpected -- the result is a set of uniquely lifting songs.

4. Ane Brun - Changing Of The Seasons
Outstanding Norwegian singer-songwriter delivers fractured, emotional compositions never less than utterly beautiful.

3. The Weepies - Hideaway
The name and deceptively twee arrangements can't hide the fact that this is a collection of consistently excellent songs.

2. Damien Jurado - Caught In The Trees
Our greatest living songwriter works the magic of his misery once more using an acoustic guitar and the soul in his throat, backed by a band who, playing live, gives you a reassuring smile that sadly eludes the burdened genius at the front.

1. Sun Kil Moon - April
Hazy, sprawling songs of unfathomable gorgeousness.

Monday, December 17, 2007

Top 20 Albums, 2007

This year’s top 20, in words, with albums 21-40 in lazy list form. People who haven’t been paying attention always say it’s been a bad year. People who buy more CDs than they ought to always say it’s been a good year. I think it’s been a very, very good year.
20. Dan Wilson – Free Life. If this had been available on eight-track cassette in the early 1970s, would my Dad have been playing it in his car alongside Abba and the Carpenters? It’s really that straightforward – a singer-songwriter writing well-crafted songs to sing along to. In the back, the kids sing along too. Nothing not to like about that.
19. The Innocence Mission – We Walked In Song. The reason that The Innocence Mission exist is to provide an aural definition of the word ‘gorgeous’ in the musical lexicon. They haven’t changed their sound in almost two decades, and there’s no reason for them to. Only their sudden conversion to an industrial goth-noise outfit would prevent me unquestioningly buying their perfect and elegiac discs for another 20 years.
18. The Watson Twins – Southern Manners. Imagine two artistically talented twin sisters from the US south making guitar-based music, and I bet you know what this harmonic-Americana eight-song CD sounds like before you’ve even heard it. On its cover the twins pose in silhouettes as a simulated vulva, overtly suggesting a tempting surface of beauty that doesn’t disappoint once you’ve immersed yourself inside. I am enamoured.
17. Laura Veirs – Saltbreakers. Another unsung singer who effortlessly stamps her own identity on successive albums of bitter-sweetness all draped in intricately acoustic guitars. Looks like a librarian, sings like a nightingale. Or a "nattingale", as she so charmingly warbles.
16. Feist – The Reminder. Mrs Stay-At-Home Indie-Pop latched onto Feist after seeing her on Saturday Night Live, and she was all set to buy this until I pointed out we already had it at home. Tsk, she only needed to pay attention a little to the vast pile of CDs by the stereo with the invisible ‘2007’ marker. I sometimes wonder what working women do with their spare mental space. They should stay at home, bake cakes, raise the kids, and make wonderfully dreamy, singalong music like Feist.
15. Tracey Thorn – Out Of The Woods. The first Tracey Thorn solo album, A Distant Shore, came out in 1982, and I used to listen to its solo acoustic meanderings while staring out my bedroom window hoping that the girl from three doors up would walk past, think I was deep and sensitive, then snog me. With Everything But The Girl intervening (between the two Thorn albums, not me and the girl from three doors up), it’s taken a quarter of a century for her second, but amazingly (seeing as EBTG have been, to my ears, largely dull) it’s been worth the wait. Left alone, she’s still an outstanding songwriter, even if now the backdrop’s all R&B arrangements and enhanced production values. So, none of the scratchy guitar and whiny voice that leant her first disc its fresh-girl genius, but a worthy follow-up, even if it’s all grown up.
14. Maria Taylor – Lynn Teeter Flower. A second sweet slice of what I’d happily call cake-shop pop if it wasn’t stranded so high up on the banks of the mainstream by the vagaries of misled taste. If the world was a just place, this kind of music would be going gold. Go on, try it. Honestly, cake’s really good for the soul.
13. Jesse Sykes And The Sweet Hereafter – Like Love, Lust And The Open Halls Of The Soul. No one seems to have heard of Jesse Sykes, yet every time I play her records, people ask me for her name. Her lisping, whispering voice creeps into ears and rests there like a transient and benign underground pleasure you know might just wake up one day and kill you from within. Not that I can think of any better ways to die.
12. Kristin Hersh – Learn To Sing Like A Star. This one had the benefit of a release early in the year, otherwise I’d just have filed it along with all the other mostly stunning Hersh albums on the shelf -- some peoples’ genius you end up taking for granted. But with the benefit of iPod shuffle, it just kept coming back, and getting better and better, and all the paranoid frenzy alternating with soothing bedtime threnodies came through with its usual depth of emotion and sheer, shocking brilliance.
11. Au Revoir Simone – The Bird Of Music. Every year needs a lo-fi, home made electronic album composed by unlikely musicians who just sat down and started harmonizing for the hell of it. Player instructions: start the drum machine, press a synth button, then sing along. Listener’s instructions: sit back and enjoy. Just occasionally, as on this disc, it works almost perfectly.
10. Steve Earle – Washington Square Serenade. One of those discs I bought because it was another Steve Earle album, and I usually buy the new Steve Earle album because I just feel that I ought to. That’s not the best reason to buy a CD, but this time it worked, with this being his best since the mighty collaboration with the Del McCoury Band a few years back. Could be that his sixth marriage, to country singer Alison Moorer, has given him an inspirational kick aside from misery and litigation. ‘City Of Immigrants’ is vibrant, political and celebratory singalong all in one.
9. Rilo Kiley – Under The Blacklight. Pristine pop. You start off hearing all kinds of semi-familiar tunes from songs you think you know but can’t quite pin down. You end up not caring, because the crystal clarity of Jenny Lewis’ vocal and all that backs her up make you play this disc on multi-repeat. How can a song sung by a woman about a man being seduced by a precocious 15-year-old sound so breezy and innocent?
8. Wilco – Sky Blue Sky. I can never quite grasp Wilco or why people, myself included, tend to deify them. I wouldn’t know where to start in their catalogue of achievement while trying to convert a reluctant listener. I couldn’t, off the top of my head, sing my favourite refrain off ‘Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.’ Yet if I could only take the CDs of one band on an east-to-west coast road trip, they’d be Wilco’s. I could listen to them for four days and four nights and still find something new in every song. At least I reckon I could. I should try it sometime and see.
7. Iron & Wine - The Shepherd’s Dog. A beefed up sound was definitely the way to go for the bearded wonder that is Iron & Wine. There’s the same quasi-mystical aura that surrounds his songs, but there’s more effort to build them up, take them places, and fade them out again. One review I read complained some of the songs went on too long, but for me these songs could meander on their hypnotic way for hours, provided I was in the mood for sitting back, shutting my eyes, and staring at the dark in a world of breathy vocals and weaving guitars.
6. The Shins – Wincing The Night Away. ‘Phantom Limb’ is song of the year, and the problem with producing a song so magnificent is usually that the rest of the disc can struggle to stay in touch. Mostly the distance is close enough to make this a successful, if more expansive and more ambitious, follow-up to previous triumphs. The words are either dead profound or they’re nonsense - either way, I haven’t a clue what these songs are about, but it really doesn’t matter. In pop, context is king.
5. Robert Wyatt – Comicopera. Wyatt shifts our ideas of perceived musical normality and allows us to receive sound across new waves. The crown prince of atonality resides in the town where I was born (Louth, in Lincolnshire) and I like the idea of all this weirdness being conceived in the air where I screamed my first complaints. At times playful, weirdly flat, and jazzy, but mostly just on its own perfectly tempered wold of nasal beauty altogether.
4. Brandi Carlile – The Story. Need a seat on the underground? Try hitting the high notes when you’re listening on your iPod. Passion and pop rolled into one, with more than enough edge to stop songs that could, in the hands of the wrong producer, have lapsed into AOR. Or maybe it is, and that’s what I’m into nowadays.
3. Magnolia Electric Co. – Sojourner Boxed Set. Most boxed sets are compilations, live sets or outtakes. There are very few that are effectively quadruple albums of entirely original material, plus documentary DVD, wrapping paper and forged medallion. On top of that, the quality of its slow-burning melancholy is maintained pretty much throughout, and Jason Molina’s fixation with earth’s orbital muse stands as the most productive man-to-moon relationship in musical history. Ache to Z.
2. The National – Boxer. Vocals that range from a murmur to a growl, backed by a band never short on ways to accentuate the mood within the melody. The National Sound is a national asset that deserves its own listening booth at the Smithsonian.
1. The New Pornographers – Challengers. With more hooks than a hardware shop, this deserves the year’s best album award for its consistently strong songs and its peppy pace. Makes you move, makes you want to sing, deludes you that you’re young. Empowerment pop of the highest order.
The rest:
21. Jens Lekman – Night Falls Over Kortedala
22. Band of Horses – Cease To Begin
23. Dean & Britta – Back Numbers
24. Mary Gauthier – Between Daylight And Dark
25. Thurston Moore – Trees Outside The Academy
26. Anjani Thomas – Blue Alert
27. Josh Ritter – The Historical Conquests of Josh Ritter
28. PJ Harvey – White Chalk
29. Ryan Adams – Easy Tiger
30. Evan McHugh – From The Second Chair
31. Jeremy Fisher – Goodbye Blue Monday
32. Caribou – Andorra
33. Over The Rhine – Trumpet Child
34. Zap Mama – Supermoon
35. Oliver Mtukudzi – Tsimba Itsoka
36. Sonia Leigh – Run Or Surrender
37. Richmond Fontaine – Thirteen Cities
38. Bright Eyes – Cassadaga
39. Of Montreal – Hissing Fauna, Are You The Destroyer?
40. Lucinda Williams – West

Other Years: 2006, 2004



Tuesday, December 12, 2006

2006: Top 20 Albums

Ah, boys and their end-of-year lists. I'm confident that one year before I'm 80 I'll perhaps grow out of it, and that it will suddenly strike me as unimportant to document what music I liked best that just happened to be released in the previous 12 months, and why. And I'll realise that no one else much cares, and that these lists are like people recalling their dreams - we're only really interested in our own. 


On the other hand, I enjoyed reading back my Top 40 albums entry from 2004 yesterday because it's going to make me go back and listen to a lot of that stuff again (I tell you, I'm through with twothousandandbloodysix for now). So I'm doing this for me too, because the chances are I'll have forgotten I even own half of this stuff in twelve months' time.

A great year for new music, incidentally. But then I always say that.


1. Syd Matters – Syd Matters
A French band singing in English, crafting low-key songs from acoustic guitars and synthesisers that sound like they’re coming from somewhere in the heart of America. Sublime.

2. Grandaddy – Just Like The Fambly Cat
Oh how I’ll miss them. The sweetest pop, conjured from sugar-coated guitars and creamy vanilla keyboard riffs that catch you in mid-air and take you, time and again, to a strange sort of upbeat melancholia. Which doesn’t make sense, but it makes you tingle.

3. Pat Metheny & Brad Mehldau – Metheny Mehldau
Metheny produces an astonishing album every year, and this time he hooks up with pianist Brad Mehldau to produce this masterpiece. Maybe there are people who could criticise music like this, but I’m not worthy. They probably knocked this out in a couple of days and had another ten tracks they didn’t use. They just sat down and played. Genius on tap.

4. Damien Jurado – And Now That I’m In Your Shadow
Jurado gets quieter every year, though possibly better too, plaintive vocals dragging his acoustic guitar almost reluctantly up to the mic to serve up yet another superb set of songs. One of America’s greatest and most prolific living songwriters.

5. Bonnie “Prince” Billy – The Letting Go
At last we can see the melody through the misery. Although Will Oldham is a superlative songwriter, this is his first album I can say, hand on heart, that I’ve actually enjoyed listening to. Less clouded arrangements and the singing of Dawn McCarthy seem to have helped engineer the breakthrough. On the CD insert there’s even a picture of him smiling. Because there’s nowt as funny as folk.

6. Brisa Roché - The Chase
Another French singer delivering mainly English-language numbers in a stylistic smorgasbord marked by its confidence, its coquettishness and its quality. Jazzy, folkish, and some vintage indie too: there are all kinds of every song delivered in a voice that tells you you’d be an idiot to fall in love with Brisa. But you’re probably doing it anyway.

7. The Handsome Family – Last Days of Wonder
The Handsome Family are the logical successors to Johnny Cash, writing deep, dark tunes that are underscored by a healthy gallows humour and irresistible singalong choruses. Check out ‘Flapping Your Broken Wings’ , which is not a morbid paean to an injured bird but a love song about a drunken night trespassing on the golf course.

8. Hem – Funnel Cloud
Just gorgeous from start to finish, Hem’s third album is another feast of elegiac, slow-burning threnodies. Quietly brilliant.

9. The Hidden Cameras – Awoo
And to think I found this band by accident because I got them mixed up with Camera Obscura. With tunes coming out of every orifice, THC love to sing things like ahoo and hehay and doowoop, punctuating their punchy socio-sexual commentaries with sardonic harmonies. Their sparse but aggressive pop attacks might be an acquired taste, but if it’s your kind of twang then the reward is this: these boys don’t come close to writing bad songs.

10. Sonic Youth – Rather Ripped
I can only think of Van Morrison in terms of such longevity and consistence built around a single style of song. This is yet another cracking foursquare album of Sonic Midlife, with only the odd half-hearted track (‘Sleepin Around’) you might expect to dog entire recordings in a band of this age. The mellow ‘Turquoise Boy’ is even one for your Mum’s iPOd.

11. Lila Downs – La Cantina
What’s not to like about US-Mexican singer Lila Downs? She celebrates eating, drinking and worthy trans-border causes in a voice like expensive chocolate – sweet, strong and a joy to taste, but with the slightest edge of bitter roughness. You’ll dance and weep all in one go.

12. Electric President – S/t
Electronic lo-fi songs pumped along by mutating beats, button-twiddling, the odd guitar, and fragile but endearing vocals. Low-budget-made-by-unknowns album of the year.

13. Solomon Burke – Nashville
Isn’t country music just soul music with a pedal steel? Burke goes back to his career origins with this gutsy, absorbing collection that takes American music on a journey within itself, emerging triumphant in every song.

14. Johnny Cash – American Recordings V: A Hundred Highways
The last of the last recordings, facing death in a sombre, resigned frame of voice, occasionally breaking out to wave the Bible and shout to the heavens. Not the best of the American Recordings, but by no means a slouch either, even though the arrangements were added two years after his death. Not that I’d have noticed if I hadn’t been told.

15. Lambchop – Damaged
If Kurt Wagner ever has grandchildren, he’ll tell them stories by sitting them around the fire and murmuring narratives over the top of a barely audible guitar. Hopefully they’ll be mesmerised, because this music is timeless, unique and so mellifluous that, if I could only take one band with me to my coffin, it would have to be Lambchop.

16. Stuart A. Staples – Leaving Songs
Although this singer wouldn’t be far behind. Staples’ voice seems to barely touch the air, yet it’s as affecting as the loudest operatic tenor. Just like The Tindersticks, it’s great clear-the-party fare, leaving you on the sofa, soaked in sadness but happy that everyone went home to leave you alone with the music.

17. Juana Molina – Son
Argentine electro-folk singer, who weaves all kind of weird and wonderful noises in and out of her softly softly compositions. A dreamy, hypnotic Latino-trip.

18. Alejandro Escovedo – The Boxing Mirror
The nearest I can come to categorising Escovedo, now happily recovered from hepatitis C, is to call him a Texan Nick Cave, making songs of dry discord and dark-eyed stories steeped in jagged riffs that call on all kinds of musical traditions associated with the border area and far beyond too. Start, as the record does, in ‘Arizona’, and if you like that (and you couldn’t possibly not), take it from there.

19. Vienna Teng – Dreaming Through The Noise
This record is almost perfect. It might strike you as very Californian in its positive sincerity, backed with pristine, music school piano. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, because the songs are so strong they’ll wipe away any reservations you have that Teng is just too damned clean. A huge talent.

20. Califone – Roots And Crowns
Wilco bumps into Brian Eno in a bluegrass parallel universe. They do drugs and accidentally sit on some instruments that are lying around. (By the way, that’s not a bad thing.)

Other albums I really liked:
Flaming Lips – At War With The Mystics
Ali Farka Toure – Savane
Josh Ritter – The Animal Years
Bettie Serveert – Bare Stripped Naked
Half-Handed Cloud – Halos and Lassos
Gomez – How We Operate
Willard Grant Conspiracy – Let It Roll
Lisa Germano – In The Maybe World
Frank Black – Fast Man, Raider Man
Sufjan Stevens – The Avalanche
Mindy Smith – Long Island Shore
Camera Obscura – Let’s Get Out Of This Country
Isobel Campbell & Mark Lanegan – Ballad of the Broken Seas
Chatham County Line – Speed of the Whippoorwill
Drive-By Truckers – A Blessing and a Curse
Golden Smog – Another Fine Day
India Arie – Testimony, Vol. 1
Richard Julian – Slow New York
Roddy Frame – Western Skies
Sleepthief – The Dawnseeker
The Sleepy Jackson – Personality
TV On The Radio – Return To Cookie Mountain
Beth Orton – The Comfort of Strangers

Other albums I liked, but with minor reservations :
Calexico – Garden Ruin
Isolée – Western Shore
Mogwai – Mr. Beast
Morrissey – Ringleader of the Tormentors
Neko Case – Fox Confessor Brings The Flood
Ollabelle – Riverside Battle Songs
Stereolab – Fab Four Suture
Shawn Mullins – 9th. Ward Pickin’ Parlor
Sarah Harmer – I’m A Mountain
T-Bone Burnett – The True False Identity

Reissues/compilations:
Lambchop – The Decline of Country and Western Civilisation Part II
Hem – No Word From Tom (check out their version of ‘Rainy Night In Georgia’)

Letdowns:
Belle & Sebastian – The Life Pursuit (too slick, too flat, too few decent songs)
Cat Power – The Greatest (Not by a long way. No power or cat left there either)
Yo La Tengo – I Am Not Afraid Of You And I Will Kick Your Ass (but this record will still be rubbish)

Thursday, December 09, 2004

2004: Top 40 Albums

Paste magazine wrote recently that it receives 750 new CDs to review every month, and to buy them all would cost you around $10,000. And I think I’m profligate for having bought, or received, 41 discs released this year. Only The Finn Brothers’ mediocre ‘Everyone Is Here’ failed to make the list, while Tift Merritt at number 40 is the only record here I’d unreservedly hold back from recommending.

Why all the verbiage? Because every year I mindlessly compile a list, and the rankings are almost arbitrary. This year I compiled the list, listened to every disc carefully anew, wrote down why I liked it or not, and then I swapped them all about, radically in some cases. Bjork, for example, slumped from a teen position to number 36, and Lambchop slipped a good two dozen places in the course of a week’s aural rumination.

Of course this list fails to take into account the other 8,000 odd CDs that came out in 2004. But as a mental exercise it at least helped me understand what I’m looking for in music, and what I get out of it. Feel free to browse.

40. Tift Merritt – Tambourine
Rocky sound from the young country diva who wowed on her 2002 debut ‘Bramble Rose’. Opener ‘Stray Paper’ is a seller, but second track ‘Wait It Out’ heads for AOR territory without a pedal steel in sight, and that’s where the record stays pretty much for the duration until the penultimate ‘Laid A Highway’. The songs aren’t as strong, and it’s a mystery why a label as good as Lost Highway would allow one of their young hopefuls to drift this way. Unless, for some reason, that’s where she wants to go. “I’ve got to get back in the arms of the man who loves me,” she sings. Sorry luv, but you’ll need to get back on the old acoustic before I’ll allow that to happen. Until then I’m firmly holding Mindy Smith’s hand (see number 7) at the Grand Ole Opry.

39. Franz Ferdinand – Franz Ferdinand
A fair pop record. Successfully evoking early 80s indie-pop while writing a handful of quite storming songs is, by current chart standards, an achievement of sorts. Still, too many non-descript filler songs suggest a limited repertoire and pose the big question: where do they go from here?

38. Dave Kusworth and Tenderhooks – Like ‘Wonderland Avenue’ In A Cold Climate
Former Jacobite and Nikki Sudden collaborator is only worth still investigating if you’re A Fan (at least that’s how I came to own this one), as there’s nothing here he hasn’t done before, and only a few hints of the outstanding ballads he’s composed in the past. Lilting acoustic is what he’s always done best, but here there’s too much self-indulgent guitar licking, faceless drum patterns and lack of variation to pique the listener. ‘Are You The Girl’ and the sweet ‘Tell Me About Your Love’, especially, make an extra effort on the melody front, and ‘Street Imagery’ closes impressively, but otherwise I was just as impressed by the sleeve and disc photography of decaying urban Britain.

37. Lambchop – Awcmon/No Youcmon
If you’ve got enough Lambchop songs to last you a lifetime, there’s probably little need to look into this sprawling double release. While I admire their prodigiousness as much as I love their languid music, the crucial element of surprise has long since fled. There’s material here stamped with their trademark quality, but throw away the superficial instrumentals - which sound like aimless studio jams that could be used as TV theme music - and some childish-sounding, underdeveloped songs like ‘Shang A Dang Dang’, and you’re left with not quite a whole side of worthwhile Lambchop standards. I realised too that I’d mostly listened to the discs as background music, and that far too many of the songs didn’t bear close scrutiny.

36. Tim Booth – Bone
James were a band that seemed to be maligned by critics as much for selling records as anything else, but I couldn’t help loving Tim Booth’s voice and his songs, despite a number of apparently good reasons why this was unacceptable. ‘Bone’ is hardly a reinvention, but if Booth’s your bag then you’ll be happy enough with songs like the title tune, ‘Discover’, ‘Fall In Love’, ‘Down To The Sea’ and ‘Careful What You Say’. Still, unless he explores some radical new musical avenues, it’s hard to see anything but a diminishment into obscurity. He looks so contented with life in the covering booklet’s photos, it could be that’s what he’s after.

35. Bjork – Medulla
It’s significant that Robert Wyatt appears on this album, because a lot of the songs remind me of his wobbly, troubling and stupendously groundbreaking song ‘Born Again Cretin’. I wish the songs on this were half as good. It’s a brave move, alright, to record a batch of latter-day Icelandic madrigals, and at times there are plenty of moments where you think it’s about to pay off. But not enough, and too often the album drifts back into atonal aimlessness. You can’t deal with it in one sitting. It would have been far better as a one- or two-song idea. But at least it’s a musical landmark – the first pop album ever directly influenced by Gesualdo.

34. Jon Langford – All The Fame Of Lofty Deeds
Political neo-cowboypunkabilly fun.

33. Greg Brown – Honey In The Lion’s Head
The deepest growl in North American music belongs to Greg Brown, and whether he’s covering traditional folk ballads, children’s songs (check out the sinister but addictive take on ‘Who Killed Cock Robin?’) or his odd self-penned compositions you can’t help but feel warmed, at the same time as watching your back for the bad guy’s bullet. The slack delivery of “Railroad Bill, Railroad Bill/Never worked, never will,” is my favourite song about unemployment ever.

32. Tom Russell – Indians Cowboys Horses Dogs
If the mercurial Lila Downes and the cracking Calexico have created a category for US-Mexican border music, Tom Russell’s joining the club. His only problem is that opening track ‘Tonight We Ride’ is so rodeo-rumbustious that the rest of the album has trouble living up to the standard he’s set. There are a couple of passionately delivered Dylan covers, likewise Woody Guthrie’s ‘East Texas Red’, a jaunty version of ‘El Paso’, and a handful of fine self-penned songs, the best of which are the closing, low-key numbers ‘The Ballad of Edward Abbey’ and ‘Little Blue Horse’. Keynote desert folk music.

31. Leonard Cohen – Dear Heather
As laid back as you might expect from a wise old septuagenarian, maybe just too laid back when you think it’s only a handful of years since he was still writing revelly rousers like ‘Closing Time’ and ‘The Future’. Stick it on late with the lights low and a very special lady (or lad) to dinner…bloody hell, Leonard’s become the New Age Jewish retiree’s answer to Barry White. There are songs in there somewhere, but you may not have the patience to wait for them. You know, just like when you’re behind the pensioner who can’t find her bus pass and you have to resist the urge to push past and go sit with your mate Franz Ferdinand who’s already larking about on the top deck. Just relax. There’s no hurry, says Zenard. Go with the (very slow) flow.

30. Joropo Music – Si soy llanero
Fast and fearless music from the Orinoco plains of Colombia, with mesmerising musicianship from weathered travelling plainsmen I’d the fortune to catch doing two completely different sets at this year’s Smithsonian Folklife Festival. The vocals, both male and female, are as strong as horses, with some astonishing harp playing, (yes, they carry that thing across the plains) lightningly intricate bandola, and a rhythm section of bass, cuatro guitar and maracas. The best thing to come out of Colombia since Carlos Valderrama.

29. Grant-Lee Phillips – Virginia Creeper
Opens with violin, musette, acoustic guitars and breathy vocals on ‘Mona Lisa’, setting the tone for a strong but low-key outing that grows with every listen. Sometimes it seems a little too smooth, and with these kinds of instruments and folk-country pop songs you wish there could be a few rougher edges, a few more ambitious reaches both vocally and violinically. The several moments of loveliness on songs like ‘Waking Memory’ need a clatter, a scratch and a screech to complement the annoyingly flawless production. Or maybe that’s criticism for criticism’s sake, because it’s still a fine collection.

28. Elvis Costello and the Impostors – The Delivery Man
Lifetime Achievement In Songwriting Award No. 3. Costello’s voice wore me out years ago, and I half wish I didn’t have to listen to his new albums any more. I more than half wish that he would let Lucinda Williams, who accompanies him here on ‘There’s A Story In Your Voice’, sing the whole record. ‘The Judgment’ he wrote for Solomon Burke, in whose repertoire it perhaps should have stayed. The problem’s compounded by the fact that several of the songs on here are as good as anything he’s ever written. ‘Country Darkness’, ‘The Delivery Man’ and ‘Nothing Clings Like Ivy’ would stand out even more if the other songs weren’t competing. More guest singers, please.

27. Nikki Sudden – Treasure Island
One of Sudden’s best solo efforts for many a year, despite the embarrassing fancy dress pirate gear, though you’ve got to admire a man who must be nearly 50 who’s not self-conscious enough to give a shit. The unashamedly derivative (ah, that explains the pirate gear) ex-Swell Map starts with a rocker (‘Looking For A Friend’), a country roller (‘Break Up’) and a romantic heart-tugger on growing old but keeping your (doubtless inner) beauty (‘Stay Bruised’). ‘Russian River’ is a classic Sudden troubadour‘s lament, but even more outstanding is the double track ‘When The Lord’/’Never Let Me Go’, both basically the same song that half way through shifts its melody without a flinch, and which will have you swaying to its gospel-soul singalong. Nice one.

26. The Magnetic Fields – i
Deep-throated synth-songs include one of the pure pop moments of the year in the danceable ‘I Thought You Were My Boyfriend’, and it’s almost matched by ‘I Don’t Believe You’. The black comedy of ‘I Wish I Had An Evil Twin’ is another highlight (“My evil twin would lie and steal/And he would stink of sex appeal/All men would writhe/Beneath his scythe/He’d send the pretty ones to me”), ‘In An Operetta’ is delightful low camp, and ‘It’s Only Time’ is a sad last dance, but despite the cellos and flutes to supplement the electronics, too many of these songs are sketches that need a melodic push to take them to the next level. Enjoyable blueprint for a future cabaret, but overall not essential.

25. Ben Kweller – On My Way
Nerd rock. Its rawness reminds me at times of a young Billy Bragg, except Kweller sings, plays and writes better than English William. The geeky cover photo shows the boy in a tanktop, posing with wolves on a mountainside, and it makes you think, “Ass-kicking dork!” When he sings about how much he likes to hide from the world in his apartment you think, “Aw God bless him and his ham-fisted but catchy punkish sensibilities.” ‘On My Way’ is early Dylanesque from the strumming to the lyrics, yet he carries it off wonderfully. One of those discs where the low cost production sounds in perfect place. He should get better.

24. Air - Talkie Walkie
Lightweight, effortless music, like slow ELO. As your Mum might once have said about a boiled egg, “There’s nothing not to like about it.” ‘Cherry Blossom Girl’ is like a bowl of Angel Delight. It doesn’t knock you off your chair, and you don’t freak out about it, but you wouldn’t object to a little more. ‘Run’ is like a summer evening’s breeze – close your eyes and let it gently tingle your skin. ‘Another Day’ is pure chocolate warmth. ‘Mike Mills’ says “We can compose lush and beautiful film music,” and maybe that’s what they should do from now on – their soundtrack to The Virgin Suicides is my second favourite film score ever. Quit whistling, just make sounds.

23. Camper van Beethoven – New Roman Times
In the year’s most unfashionable move, reformed 1980s college-circuit underdogs make an anti-war concept album covering their customary range of genres from country, eastern European hootenanny instrumental folk and indie-pop through heavy metal and even disco. More or less, it works very well. And although the odd contrived track, such as the awful ‘Hippie Chix’, could have ended up on the studio floor without too many tears, there’s a sequence of fine tunes through the middle of the album that stand out as good old-fashioned political singalong. If you’ve never heard them, check out ‘Our Beloved Revolutionary Sweetheart’ and ‘Key Lime Pie’ from the late 80s first. If you like those, get this.

22. Modest Mouse – Good News For People Who Love Bad News
An unexpected grower, this one. An intelligent pop record that’s noisy in all the right places, but quiet when it needs to be, if that makes sense. At first I thought they sounded like a novelty act, and the vocalist irritated me (a bit shouty at times), but then the hooks, the variations and the all-round inventiveness overrode all dislikes. ‘Bury Me With It’ is an ageing man’s cynical tribute to lost idealism: ‘We were aiming for the moon/We were shooting at the stars/But the kids were just shooting at the buses and the cars.” In ‘Bukowksi’, God’s a control freak, and who’d want to be like that? “You were so true to yourself/You were true to no one else,” they sing tartly on ‘Black Cadillacs’. An album packed with dark humour, quirky riffs, anarchic brass and great melodies.

21. The Old Crow Medicine Show – O.C.M.S.
So not all good American country-folk music these days is made by the talented but miserable. This is a wild and bumpy yee-haa Appalachian hayride, even though the songs are about snorting cocaine and wacked-out ‘Nam vets. Five trad songs, five originals, and a fine take on Dylan’s ‘Wagon Wheel’ round off a rollicking racket of a record. You can imagine them smashing their banjos onstage at the end of the night.

20. The National – Cherry Tree
More deep American voices and acoustic guitars writing holy songs on this mini-LP continuation of last year’s enticing ‘Sad Songs For Dirty Lovers’. Five fine new tracks here. ‘All Dolled-Up In Straps’ sees the coffee-dark vocals jump a scale, and the result is a piano-backed, downbeat pop song of pathos and longing. The title track nags you till you start nodding your head like a crazed woodpecker, before it brings you down to the stirring hypnosis of ‘About Today’. After this there’s a live take of the thunderousing ‘Murder Me Rachael’, then a sole guest track from Padma Newsome, who has a deep voice and an acoustic guitar…

19. Tom Waits – Real Gone
Lifetime Achievement In Songwriting Award No. 2. ‘Sins Of The Father’ cites a world that “turns on nothing but money and dread” and “it’s much too late to throw the dice again”. Waits sounds more tired than ever, his music half-wasted, and it’s little surprise to find this disc is not a set of slickly produced bubblegum pop hits aimed at the early teenage market. “You know I feel like a preacher waving a gun around,” could be his headstone’s epitaph. If you’re not prepared by two decades of Waits devotion, it’s a challenging listen (my wife won’t tolerate him for more than five seconds), but it’s a rare gift to sound like an out-of-luck bum and a musical genius simultaneously. And just when you feel like your head can’t get shaken any more, along come songs like the spooky ‘How’s It Gonna End’ (probably with several bangs on a dustbin lid), the dead lovely ‘Dead And Lovely’, and the wistfully morbid ‘Green Grass’.

18. Nancy Sinatra – Nancy Sinatra
I’ve always hated U2 with a passion, so it’s been something of a long process to admit that the best song on this album is ‘Two Shots of Happy, One Shot Of Sad’, written by Bono and The Edge. It works because they’ve written it with an eye for Sinatra’s vocal style (actually it was originally written for Frank, but he was too old and ill to record it), a classic late night jazz-lounger. Jarvis Cocker also plays to Nancy’s strengths on ‘Don’t Let Him Waste Your Time’ and ‘Baby’s Coming Back To Me’ (they could have been recorded in 1967), whereas Morrissey’s ‘Let Me Kiss You’, while a superb song, is clearly a Morrissey song being sung by Nancy Sinatra. Still, from the opening country rocker ‘Burnin’ Down The Spark’ onwards it’s a mostly compelling collection. Who couldn’t love the voice, as sultry and coquettish as ever?

17. Pale Horse and Rider – The Moody Pike
To start with, this is the best band name ever. To give you an idea, it was recorded in Kentucky. It couldn’t really have been recorded anywhere but Kentucky. I’ve never been to Kentucky, but this album is how I think Kentucky is, or how Kentucky ought to be. There are no cars, just pale horses, with riders. There are no synthesisers, but lots of pedal steel, banjo, even the odd glockenspiel. No artifice, just sorrow, expressed in ‘Bruises Like Badges’ and the crashabout ‘Weight Of My Soul’. Cheer yourself up and leave it on the shelf. But then you’ll never get to experience the beauty of ‘Annabelle’.

16. Giant Sand – Is All Over The Map
Apposite title. Like Camper van Beethoven, Giant Sand is a stylistic palette, masters of whatever they take on. Here, there’s even more adventure and experimentation than on CVB’s, taking you from mind-losing headbang through fuzzy melancholy without ever quite losing a sense of thrill. The closing duet of ‘Anarchistic Bolshevistic Cowboy Bundle’/’Ploy’ sums up the overall mood, veering from Sex Pistols pastiche, through honky-tonk warbling to hotel lounge piano. ‘Cracklin Water’, ‘Hood’, ‘Napoli’ and ‘A Classico Reprise’ are all quietly brilliant. A band that is funny, idiosyncratic and exhilarating with gobsmacking consistency.

15. Tanya Donnelly – Whiskey Tango Ghosts
Poetically titled, poetically executed. Lovely, whispery songs for relaxation, meditation and melancholy moments of musing on the unattainable. There’s not a bad note, let alone a bad song, on this lilting, lenitive cut.

14. Iron And Wine – Our Endless Numbered Days
Combine iron with wine and you produce, in the material world, something unusable and indigestible. In the musical world it results in warm, but hard-edged American folk, exquisitely played out on string and backed by a deceptively saccharine vocal singing of death and war. Lyrically, ‘Free Until They Cut Me Down’ is a new take on ‘Strange Fruit’, while in musical terms it’s a startling homage to the idea of hanging for something that was worthwhile (“She’s the one who begged me/’Take me home’ “). The miracle is that all these songs will soothe you and stab you at the same time.

13. Devendra Banhart – Rejoicing In The Hands
A dream: there’s a party in a big house and everyone’s out of it. In a corner a man plays a guitar, singing weirdly, tortuously. At first you hate him and kind of want to punch him, because there are several girls paying him way too much attention. Only when you talk to him as he’s taking a break do you realise how bleedingly sincere he and his powerful, poetic songs are. He starts to play again and this time you’re more in love with him than the girls are. At the same time a part of you is lamenting that he’s a hundred times more talented than you’ll ever be. And that this is only one album of two he brought out this year, and this one alone includes 16 gripping compositions. Folk album of the decade, except for possibly its sister work, recorded at the same sessions, and which I haven’t yet heard.

12. Morrissey – You Are The Quarry
An English gentleman abroad makes a canny comeback album. Still the same supercilious lyrics that raise themselves to the funny and pertinent (“I have forgiven Jesus/For all of the love/He placed in me”) sufficiently often to stop him becoming an insufferable, posturing prick (although some may say it’s way too late for that). Oh, and there are some smashing songs too, making for one of his more consistent solo albums, perhaps second best only to the excellent ‘Vauxhall And I’. “She told me she loved me/Which means/She must be insane”, he croons on ‘How Can Anybody Possibly Know How I Feel’. How can anybody possibly care after all these years? ‘First Of The Gang To Die’ and ‘Let Me Kiss You’ are both up there or thereabouts for the Year’s Best Song Award.

11. Loretta Lynn – Van Lear Rose
Yeah right, Jack White meets Loretta Lynn. But who would have bet against the talented bastard making it completely work? As producer and arranger, White doesn’t take it over, but he’s definitely co-running this country show, and the backing to Lynn’s ad-libbed ‘Little Red Shoes’ sounds like the sort of wondrous hook a man at his creative peak can effortlessly dash off in five minutes. Goes from honky-tonk to trad country sad to White Stripes-sounding guitar intros without batting an ornery eye-lid. Freshest record of the year.

10. Kings of Convenience – Riot On An Empty Street
To say this band is Norway’s answer to Belle and Sebastian is a pithy but simplistic assessment that ignores the depth within this bottomless toy box of outstanding playthings. It’s Take 2 of the irresistible debut LP, ‘Quiet Is The New Loud’, but no complaints on that front. It’s stark, bare-bones songwriting, and the place where you’d listen to it is needlessly depicted on the CD booklet’s centre spread – rain-sopped windows with a bleak urban landscape on the other side. They’re Norwegian, they’re depressed, and they write songs so gorgeous they make you want to kiss the nearest human being (tip – don’t listen to this CD in public).

9. Wilco – A Ghost Is Born
Maybe it was because of all the feedback and the guitar solos, or maybe it was because I was given a bootleg copy with a low recording level and I didn’t have the track listing and liner notes, but it took me a long time to love this record, and usually with Wilco it only takes me a few seconds. Eventually all the runaway licks and the actually quite soothing amp shrieks started to fit in, and the songs themselves emerged from the mist as individual compositions. Without a track listing I can’t pick out any favourites, except that really long track 3, and the really nice track with piano on near the end. I should just buy it, really.

8. The Hidden Cameras – Mississauga Goddam
Are The Hidden Cameras the last band on earth still making quality, creative indie-pop? Not just that, but they make gay sex sound harmony-sweet. “I drank from the wine that came from inside the heart of his meat” (‘That’s When The Ceremony Starts’), and “I believe in the good of life as I kneel for the taste of man” (‘I Believe In The Good Of Life’) are choral-sounding hymns to homosexuality (albeit ironic in the latter’s case) built around magnificent tunes. “I want another enema/Good waste is an oxymoron/My body is an exit wound…” is scarily brilliant, while the title-track closer is a five-minute pop masterpiece on the delights of living in the small town closet. Five huge shiny stars.

7. Mindy Smith – One Moment More
Staggering debut from the latest sylph-like country überbabe, who sings and writes in such a way that on the opening track she can have you hollering passionately about what a comfort it is to let Jesus hold you in his arms. Lyrics like “Keep on believing God is/Soaring above a world that’s/Running out of love/Pouring hope out over us/His angel doves” (‘Angel Doves’) may not appeal on a cold computer screen, but put through Smith’s keening vocal talents they’re enough to make a hardened atheist experience a second coming. ‘Raggedy Ann’ will push you to attempt notes much higher than you could ever hope to reach, because you want to be up there with her. One critic called her cover of ‘Jolene’ (with Dolly Parton) “overwrought”, but if this is true she can wrought all over me, any time. Mindy Smith can write the songs to match the seven-scale wonders of her voice on numbers like the heart-hitting ‘Hurricane’ and the love-to-love ‘It’s Amazing’. It truly is.

6. Hem – Eveningland
Hem has massively expanded its sound since debut ‘Rabbit Songs’, a recording that was so slight that you sometimes doubted there was anything there at all. To start with, this sounds like a drawn out, orchestral Joni Mitchell tribute LP, until on the third and fourth listens the songs start to creep in and melt your reluctance. Get over it, this is what we listen to now we are parents. So you give in and, ceasing to care, you have to love it. Standout tracks – all of them.

5. Jim White – Drill A Hole In That Substrata And Tell Me What You See
First, ‘Static On The Radio’ is single of the year, a total ear-catching country soul song that unravels so smoothly you could skate on it. ‘Bluebird’ is better than McCartney’s song of the same name because McCartney couldn’t write a line like ”Hey Santa Claus I see your junkie eyes,” nor could he craft a heartrending poetic masterpiece of misery that’s somehow still uplifting too. Cheap girls, cheap motels, cheap Jesus driving a motor home in a song that fantasises “if we all drove motor homes, well maybe in the end, with no country to die for, we could just be friends”. It’s trailer park rap from the vocally deep South with a wit as dry as Texas, and arrangements as lush as a Bourbon-soaked feather pillow.

4. Ben Weaver – Stories Under Nails
Growl the word ‘Americana’ while slugging moonshine, belting an old tin can with a piece of scrap metal, and playing whatever old-fashioned string instrument comes to hand. Not Tom Waits, but something even better (and Waits could learn how to narrate a song properly from the track ‘John Martin’). It’s so rootsy you can smell the damp earth, which was probably dug up from an overgrown cemetery. And hidden in the undergrowth are these astounding songs, rambling melodies, bone-naked emotions. ‘Old Mission’ is the most evocatively melancholic song of the year: “Now my life is pitch black and I’m just counting down the days”. Weaver makes you think of abandoned garage forecourts, scowling, bearded men in crappy pick-up trucks, dishes unwashed for days. ‘Like A Wound’ is like a wound. ’40 Watt Bulb’ is beauty enchansoned as something dark and roughly delicious. Genius, truly.

3. Jesse Sykes and the Sweet Hereafter – Oh, My Girl
Reverb country – lazy strumming, acoustic and electric hooks come from all angles, topped by sensuous, wispish vocals and the most ravishing set of songs you could ever wish to hear by an open fire, or an open grave. There’s a cult cowboy film waiting to be written somewhere to go with this music, and the day I strike out west from DC along Route 66 I’ll have this playing on loop. “Don’t say it’s over/Your black eyes remind me/Of the dreaming dead,” sings Sykes, who happens to be as drop-dead loveable as her songs. ‘House By The Lake’ is the nearest you’ll get to a party atmosphere – it’s an upbeat, brass-pocked number about…death.

2. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds – Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus
Lifetime Achievement In Songwriting Award No.1. I doubt Cave could release a bad LP if he tried, but just to prove any lagging doubters wrong, he shanks out a double disc covering all his corners, from belted-out bluesy goth to cool, dark ballads, with plenty of gospelly backing singers to add to the quasi-religious imagery that as ever pervades his lyrics. Seventeen stellar tracks, with so many standouts it seems unfair to focus on a few, but ‘Breathless’, ‘Supernaturally’, ‘O Children’, ‘Get Ready For Love’, ‘Messiah Ward’ and ‘There She Goes, My Beautiful World’ could comfortably walk on to a future six-disc greatest hits boxed set. You could buy this record alone and claim that 2004 had been a great year for music.

1. Mark Lanegan Band – Bubblegum
Come on a trip, and let the Mark Lanegan Band provide the drugs. I don’t think I’ve ever seen, let alone taken, a hard drug, but this disc provides a vicarious, reflective look-in, from dirty needle guitar riffs, through blissed-out, grainy lullabies, to rough cold turkey and back again. Tracking through ‘Methamphetamine Blues’/’One Hundred Days’/’Bombed’/’Strange Religion’ is as good a four-song sequence as you’ll find on any album in any year, although the closing ‘Head’/’Driving Death Valley Blues’/’Out Of Nowhere’ make it a close run thing. I’m hooked.